Star Lord!

Longbox Graveyard #86

Obscure heroes have been my stock-in-trade here at Longbox Graveyard, and I’ve enthused about quite a few of them, whether it was pleading for respect for Captain Marvel, remembering the still-unrealized potential of Deathlok, or lamenting the unfinished saga of Killraven and his War of the Worlds.

But among my favorite heroes, more obscure by far would be Star Lord. At least, he was obscure until this guy came along.

Chris Pratt | Star Lord | Guardians of the Galaxy

That is Chris Pratt, and until yesterday, I didn’t know who he was. Maybe you didn’t, either.

But now he’s fast-tracked to join a holy trinity of Marvel leading men named Chris (along with Chris Evans and Chris Hemsworth) because Mr. Pratt will shortly share center stage with this motley crew:

Guardians of the Galaxy

That is concept art for Guardians of the Galaxy, Marvel’s superhero/science fiction movie coming in 2014, and that guy in the center with the two guns and the funky face mask is Star Lord (sort of … as we shall see). It is shocking enough that we live in a world where there is a Guardians of the Galaxy movie in the first place, but we are really through the geek looking glass when Star Lord is a part of it (though I suppose with Rocket Raccoon also coming to the screen that anything is possible). Still, even with Marvel’s developing reputation for using every part of the buffalo, it has to rate among the least likely of unlikely twists and turns that they’ve opened up their intellectual property vault and dusted off Star Lord for the big screen.

Who is Star Lord? (Besides Chris Pratt).

He’s was one of my favorite characters, and one lost to the ages — or he was until plucked from the purgatory of Marvel’s dead file to begin his transition into the Marvel Universe in the pages of Timothy Zahn’s quasi-canonical Star-Lord #2 in 1997, followed by his eventual integration with the Guardians of the Galaxy (and even the Guardians aren’t my Guardians, but that is another column!)

The NEW Guardians of the Galaxy

Of course, this is Longbox Graveyard, the comics blog where it is always 1978, so that 1997 comic story isn’t of real interest to me. I have read a bit of the rebooted Guardians of the Galaxy, and enjoyed both that team and the new Star Lord who leads it, but he isn’t really the Star Lord (or Star-Lord!) that I remember.

This is my guy:

Marvel Preview #4

My Star Lord debuted in the black-and-white magazine pages of Marvel Preview #4 in 1976, and he is a distant echo — or maybe the distant progenitor — of the Star Lord now fast-tracked for cinematic stardom. My Star-Lord practiced astrology (for an issue, at least), was loved by his sentient ship, had a pistol that fired blasts of the four elements, and he had a hyphen! A hyphen, do you hear? He was Star-Lord back in the day, none of this Star Lord business!

He was also a bit of a jerk. And definitely NOT a part of the Marvel Universe.

The old Marvel black-and-white magazines were often a place of experimentation. Sold for a buck and not covered by the Comics Code Authority, Marvel’s mags sometimes touched on more adult content than their color comic book line. Dozens (hundreds?) of them came and went over the ages, but aside from Savage Sword of Conan, few of them got much traction in the market. Marvel Preview, in particular, was all over the place, with a rotating cast of editors that all seemed intent on taking the magazine in a different direction. It’s a new character try-out book! It’s a showcase for edgy takes on costumed heroes! It’s a standard-bearer for the legitimacy of graphic fiction! It has tits so it can compete with Heavy Metal!

In its day, Marvel Preview was all of those things, but of interest today is that Marvel Preview was the birthplace of Star-Lord.

Star-Lord, by Bernie Wrightson

Bernie Wrightson‘s Star-Lord frontispiece for Marvel Preview #4

Developed by Steve Englehart under the editorial direction of Marv Wolfman, Star-Lord told the tale of Peter Quill, a young man who saw his mother killed by space aliens, and made it his life’s mission to avenge her death. Star-Lord’s origin story in Marvel Preview #4 is fast-paced and action-packed, during which we learn the astrological configuration of the sky at Peter’s birth approximated that of the birth of Christ; that the young man had a psychopathic father who wanted to kill his son at birth; that Peter’s mother got whacked by space lizards; and that Peter was a brilliant astronaut but not so nice a guy.

Steve Gan & Steve Englehart, Marvel Preview #4

whacked by space lizards (bummer)

In subsequent interviews, Englehart said he intended Peter Quill to be a bit of a dick — right down to giving him a prickly name — and that over a series of stories he intended to chart Peter’s gradual march toward enlightenment or at least being a mellow dude.
Englehart would leave Marvel before penning another chapter in his magnum opus, so what we have is this brisk and sometimes harsh origin story that doesn’t try to redeem our hero in any way.

The story sees Peter aboard a space station when an alien presence promises to turn someone into a superhero. Peter is instantly disqualified by his NASA bosses … then adopts a novel approach to fulfill his destiny. I believe it is singular in that Peter more-or-less steals a Star-Lord identity intended for a more worthy character. It would be like some mentally-unstable schmo laid something heavy across the back of Hal Jordan‘s head and took for his own that Green Lantern power ring proffered by Abin Sur.

Peter was so driven to get into space to avenge his mother’s death that he resorted to mass murder — I mean, how else are we to interpret this particular scene …

Steve Gan & Steve Englehart, Marvel Preview #4

… and I’m not sure we can excuse his behavior just because it leads to him becoming the Star-Lord, whatever the “Master of the Sun” might suggest.

Steve Gan & Steve Englehart, Marvel Preview #4

Still, it is an original superhero origin, this idea of stealing powers and identity that were supposed to go to some other character. It reminds me a bit of the story of one of my own Irish ancestors, who knocked out his brother and stole his ticket to America. Maybe that’s why this tale spoke to me, as a lad — or maybe it was because Peter and I were born in the same year of 1962, and if he was destined for some cosmic transfiguration, then maybe I was, too.

Whatever the reason, I liked Star-Lord, I liked that he was a bit of a prick, I liked his uniform and I liked that he flew around in space with a water pistol (excuse me, “element gun”). I wanted more Star-Lord, and (years) later, I got my wish, when the character received his “second launch” in Marvel Preview #11.

Star-Lord, by John Byrne & Terry Austin

This was a different Star-Lord. Englehart was gone, and with him all that astrology hooey. In it’s place was a two-fisted space opera tale, by the first-time-together superstar team of Chris Claremont, John Byrne, Terry Austin, and Tom Orzechowski. While not exactly a reboot, this was a new take on the character, picking up his adventures sufficient years into the future that our hero can be expected to have evolved past his difficult origins and become a kind of seeker and protector of the galaxy.

Citing Robert Heinlein’s “juveniles” as his primary inspiration, Claremont’s vision for Star-Lord was one of unapologetic space opera, and so we have an adventure centering on intrigue inside a stellar empire, with nobles wearing capes on the bridges of their starships, and a nifty bit of meta story-telling where we’re asked to reflect on the anachronism of men fighting for the destiny of stars by dueling with swords …

John Byrne & Chris Claremont, Marvel Preview #11

There is imagination to burn in this story, told at a breathless pace with exciting elements absorbed on the fly. Peter Quill is afraid of his own powers and potential! Peter has a secret heritage! Our hero helms a sentient, shape-changing starship that appears to be in love with him! There’s a sprawling interstellar empire out there brimming with intrigue and adventure!

If this tale had the good fortune to come out after Star Wars, instead of a few months before, Star-Lord might have become an instant superstar. Instead, John Byrne and Terry Austin moved over to X-Men with Chris Claremont to change the face of superhero comics, and Star-Lord’s next outings — in Marvel Preview #14 and #15 — failed to build on that dynamite tale from #11. Chris Claremont returned to script, but Carmine Infantino was at best serviceable on pencils. These issues were also smaller in scope and spirit of adventure than the previous tale, as Claremont abandoned the fast-paced space opera derring-do of his previous tale, opting for a planet-of-the-week kind of story that centered on Peter’s relationship with “Ship.” Having “Ship” take on humanoid female form was an interesting step (and it provided Infantino an opportunity to draw “Ship’s” female avatar in various states of undress, hubba-hubba), but the development of Peter and “Ship’s” relationship felt forced and rushed. Rather than teasing out details of “Ship’s” true nature on-the-fly as Claremont had done in issue #11, much of the character’s mystery is explained away by the end of issue #15, and the character was less intriguing for being better understood.

Carmine Infantino & Chris Claremont, Marvel Preview #14

hubba hubba

Doug Moench took the reins of Star-Lord for his final black & white adventure in Marvel Preview #18, then shepherded the character into his color era in Marvel Super-Special #10 and Marvel Spotlight #6 and #7. Moench retained Claremont’s planet-of-the-week structure but also saw Star-Lord as a vehicle for morality plays, putting the character in situations that tested his avowed and emerging pacifism. The Marvel Spotlight books were also the first Star-Lord stories published in conventional comics format, and under a Comics Code Authority stamp, which had little effect on the story, save to make Star-Lord seem that much more like any other Marvel book — indeed, looking back at it, I can see seeds being planted for Star-Lord’s eventual transition to the Marvel Universe.

Marvel Spotlight #6

The books themselves, ably illustrated by Tom Sutton, aren’t especially memorable. All of issue #6 is spent recapping and subtly cleaning up Star-Lord’s origin; issue #7 puzzlingly recaps the recap, before offering a talky and vaguely preachy parable where Peter gets involved in a karmic conflict on a planet called Heaven (which makes the preachy part inevitable, I suppose). Star-Lord seemingly becomes more homogenous by the page, but at least Moench and Sutton pull off the most convincing (and maybe the first) demonstration of the value of Star-Lord’s element gun to date.

Tom Sutton & Doug Moench, Marvel Spotlight #7

Star-Lord continued his nomadic publication ways, next appearing in Marvel Premiere #61, a Moench tale where all the gears were on the outside. “Planet Story” was a (you guessed it) planet-of-the-week story crossed with a (ta-da!) morality play. Using a bifurcated narrative to tell the same story twice, Star-Lord first encounters what from his point of view is a sentient planet along the lines of Harry Harrison’s Deathworld, where every rock and vine is out to kill him. Then we see the same tale from the living planet’s point of view, where all it wants is … love (sniff).

Marvel Premiere #61, Tom Sutton

This is all well and good, but Star-Lord has completely jumped the rails by this point. The promise of that warts-and-all-origin story and that spectacular, swashbuckling sophomore outing have given way to weak-sauce, second-tier Green Lantern-style stories. Marvel must have felt the character had come adrift, as well, as Star-Lord’s next appearance was in 1982’s Star-Lord Special Edition #1, which reprinted that great Star-Lord tale from Marvel Preview #11 (this time in color), and added a few pages of story wrapper that saw Peter reconciled with his actual and mysterious birth father, and rocketing off to new adventures with “Ship” and his old man.

Star Lord, now in color!

Star-Lord seemed to know who he was, even if his creators didn’t

And that was the end of Star-Lord. The name would next be used for a successor character, in Timothy Zahn’s 1990s-era series, before the character formally entered the Marvel Universe in 2004’s Thanos #8-12. By this point, the character was practically unrecognizable from his origins, with Peter blinged out with cybernetic inputs, “Ship” long gone, and a new uniform replacing those elegant 1970s threads of yore.

As an original vintage loyalist and curmudgeon of the first order, I came into this blog locked and loaded to blast this new character as not really being “my” Star-Lord (or Star Lord, as he is known in this brave, new, hyphen-less future) … but you know what? I can’t do it.

I can’t do it for two reasons.

Starlord re-design

First, the new Star Lord is an entertaining character. I hate the costume — he looks like a bellhop — but as Han Solo writ small and tasked with holding together the quarrelsome and bizarre new Guardians of the Galaxy, Star Lord is more readable than at any time since his inaugural appearances. His connection to that original character is one of name only but Star Lord works well in an ensemble format (who knew?).

Second, re-reading these Star-Lord books after so many years, I see there was no “there” there with the Star-Lord of my acquaintance. I thought I was a Star-Lord fan, but I see now that all I really had were memories of a promising origin story and a dynamite Claremont/Byrne/Austin space opera. Everything else published under the Star-Lord name was pretty dire — a rattling box of disparate concepts that didn’t fit together at all.

And so I consign Star-Lord back to the airless tomb of the Longbox Graveyard with a poor overall letter grade and the recommendation that you read my in-depth review of Marvel Preview #11 over at, and then drop the best two bucks you will ever spend on a color copy of that story’s reprint in Star-Lord Special Edition #1. My own issues likely won’t see the light of day again unless they improbably skyrocket in value when Star Lord leads his Guardians of the Galaxy into cinematic battle in 2014 … but maybe I shouldn’t bet against it, given the odds this peculiar character has overcome to make it this far. I suspect the best part of Star-Lord’s story is still to come.

  • Title: Star-Lord
  • Published By: Marvel Comics, 1976-1982
  • Issues Rescued From The Longbox Graveyard: Marvel Preview #4, 14, 15, 18; Marvel Super-Special #10; Marvel Spotlight #6-7, Marvel Premiere #61, Star-Lord Special Edition #1
  • LBG Letter Grade For This Run: C-minus
  • Read The Reprint:

NEXT WEDNESDAY: #87 By Any Other Name: Darkseid


About Paul O'Connor

Revelations and retro-reviews from a world where it is always 1978, published every now and then at!

Posted on February 6, 2013, in Reviews and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 34 Comments.

  1. What a strange journey Star-Lord has had through the annals of comics. I never did get into the black & white Marvel mags, but both the Englehart and Claremont versions of Star-Lord look intriguing. Both are probably just a little ahead of their time – the Englehart version looks like the anti-hero that Wolverine would popularize, and the early Claremont version looks like a Star Wars space opera, as you point out. From Byrne/Austin to Infantino? I can’t imagine a bigger art drop-off than that! It’s an interesting point you bring up that if Claremont’s mag came out a few months later, it might have been a hit. Sometimes it’s all about timing. Our consolation is a pretty good X-Men run, though. You mention that “ship” took a human female form, and it makes me wonder if the creators of “Green Lantern: The Animated Series” have read these comics, since the same thing happened there, complete with love affair. “Less intriguing for being better understood” Are you sure you’re not referring to Boba Fett? Curse you prequels! I’m shocked to see nudity here, even though it didn’t have to go through the Comics Code Authority. Is that Infantino art in the nude scene? That’s actually much better than I would have expected. Hubba hubba indeed! The sentient planet thing doesn’t look too bad to me. The dialogue seems, good, though the idea isn’t quite original (but then what is) as long as it’s well done, it’s OK with me. Are the black & whites available in TPB format?

    It doesn’t surprise me a bit that the 90’s version of Star Lord had cybernetic inputs. Didn’t every Marvel character? I assume he had guns for arms or something like that, plus lots of black leather.

    I was glad to see that a Guardians of the Galaxy movie was coming out (the 2008 series is one of the few post-1990 Marvel comics I’ve really enjoyed) and was pleasantly shocked by your movie art showing Rocket Raccoon in the picture.


    • I recommend Marvel Preview #11 by Claremont/Byrne/Austin without reservation (also the color reprint in Star-Lord Special Edition #1). The origin story from Marvel Preview #4 is also worth a look. Everything else is for completests and masochists. That living planet story might look OK in the panels I reproduced, but then imagine that same density of purple prose over each of twenty-odd pages — with the same story told twice — and you’ll see why I checked out. I like Doug Moench plenty but this was an experiment that didn’t pan out.

      I don’t want to give the wrong impression about Carmine Infantino (and yes, that his his nude above). I think he’s a fine artist, and was even better in his day — it’s just that he’s a big step down from Byrne/Austin as they were coming into their game. He was doing fill-in/inventory work at this stage of his career and it wasn’t greatly inventive. It was competent, with good storytelling, but nothing memorable … and so can’t help but seem disappointing when replacing more dynamic artists.

      As far as the nudity is concerned, there was always a little bit on display in the Marvel dollar mags, though maybe not this direct. The nudity in this Star-Lord story is innocent but exploitative. Savage Sword of Conan indulged in a bit of skin in this same era but it was both less frequent and direct, and also fit better with the story, as so many character ran around half naked in the Hyborian Age to begin with.

      So far as I know none of these Star-Lord tales have been reprinted (aside from the best of them in Star-Lord Special Edition). The originals aren’t terribly expensive but they aren’t in great supply, either — low demand offsetting the low supply I suppose.

      Thanks for reading and commenting, as always, Dave.


      • Ah, good point about the living planet being better at a glimpse than over twenty-odd pages.
        I’ll have to be on the lookout for these, maybe in the dollar bin at the LCS, which actually has a pretty large dollar section. It’s nice to know that there are a lot of Bronze Age gems (or a sort) out there that I haven’t read yet, though I’ve got my work cut out for me just re-reading my own Bronze Age gems!


  2. I’m so intrigued by how the Guardians will translate to the big screen. It seems like a match made in heaven. (I notice that Cosmo wasn’t in the promo poster, which may either be an oversight or just a decision to 86 him from the lineup.) The Guardians of the Galaxy title really didn’t do anything for me until Star-Lord took the reins–it was my first real exposure to him, and I enjoyed him a lot.


  3. I was a big fan of the Black and White comic magazines in the 70’s so I am happy to see you review Star-Lord, who I have always had a weakness for, especially the Byrne, Austin and Claremont story in Marvel Preview 11. Byrne was always much better with Austin inking him and it was a great Space Opera. But that wasn’t the only good thing they did. Arguably Marvel’s best Doc Savage adaptations took place in the black and whites. You might want to tackles the Magazines as a Podcast topic some day.


    • I read a lot of the Doc Savage pulps as a kid. I found one of them at a elementary school reading fair and got hooked; not sure how many I read, or even how many I completed, but for awhile I was a Doc Savage fan, collecting those books (and their James Bama covers). I think my enthusiasm was dealt a blow by the Ron Ely movie that came out when I was in an especially vulnerable state when it came to my Geek Identity.

      I collected a few of the Marvel Doc Savage Black & White comics but don’t much remember them. It may be time to pick at this particular scab. Thanks for the notion!


  4. CliffARobinson

    I got hooked on the Byrne version. The shape shifting ship and amazing artwork made this my favorite comic of that year. Interesting you menrion Star Wars, I distinctly remember loving it more after seeing the movie 11 times.


  1. Pingback: #85 Defenders: Who Remembers Scorpio? « Longbox Graveyard

  2. Pingback: Windhoelme (Star-Lord!) « Longbox Graveyard

  3. Pingback: Marvel Super Special #10, Winter/1979: Star-Lord | Vintage (and not so vintage) Paperbacks

  4. Pingback: Longbox Graveyard Podcast: “A Tale of Two Pitches” « Longbox Graveyard

  5. Pingback: The Longbox Graveyard Podcast Show 10: Marvel Comics — A Space Odyssey | We Talk Podcasts

  6. Pingback: The Micronauts | Longbox Graveyard

  7. Pingback: “D” Is For Deathlok! | Longbox Graveyard

  8. Pingback: Fantastic Fiftieth Issue! | Longbox Graveyard

  9. Pingback: Longbox Soapbox (Summer 2012) | Longbox Graveyard

  10. Pingback: Killraven’s War of the Worlds | Longbox Graveyard

  11. Pingback: Guardians of the Galaxy | Longbox Graveyard

  12. Pingback: Longbox Graveyard Is A Book Guy! | Longbox Graveyard

  13. Pingback: Star Lord Gallery | Longbox Graveyard

  14. Pingback: Welcome To The Wonderful World Of Cosmics | Longbox Graveyard

  15. Pingback: Iron Fist | Longbox Graveyard

  16. Pingback: Rocket Raccoon Gallery | Longbox Graveyard

  17. Pingback: Guardians of the Galaxy! | Longbox Graveyard

  18. Pingback: Guardians of the Galaxy #1 | Longbox Graveyard

  19. Pingback: Angela, Queen of Hel #1 | Longbox Graveyard

  20. Pingback: Drax #1 | Longbox Graveyard

  21. Pingback: Star-Lord #1 | Longbox Graveyard

  22. Pingback: Venom Space Knight #1 | Longbox Graveyard

  23. Pingback: Guardians of Infinity #1 | Longbox Graveyard

  24. Pingback: Rocket Raccoon And Groot #1 | Longbox Graveyard

  25. Pingback: Tell A Tale of The Guardians of The Galaxy! | Longbox Graveyard

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: