A grab-bag of five phantasmagorical mini-reviews this week!
Incredible Hulk #331-345, May 1987-July 1988
In his introduction for the first volume of the Marvel Visionaries reprinting this run, author Peter David admits that the Incredible Hulk was a book that no one really wanted to write when he took it over in 1987. And small wonder. For most of his history, the Hulk has been a great character underserved by crappy books. With Todd McFarlane on pencils, David would simultaneously take the book back to its roots (with the Hulk at war with his Bruce Banner identity) and also explore new territory (as the grey Hulk develops a persona more complex and nuanced than previously experienced).
I quite liked the dangerous, brutish personality that David developed for the Hulk, but the road story of the Hulk, Rick Jones, and Clay Quartermain hunting down Gamma Bombs was a snore (as was Bruce Banner’s marital problems with his wife, Betty), and the bad guys never rose to the broad-shouldered standard of the Hulk himself. Story themes tended toward the supernatural and morality plays, and in this they reminded me a bit of Saga of the Swamp Thing, where Alan Moore was completing his run right about the time David debuted on Hulk. But David failed to really dig into the dysfunctional side of the Hulk the way Alan Moore deconstructed Swampy — what we wind up with is a day tour of the dark side rather than an exploration of the inky blackness of the Hulk’s soul.
This will sound strange coming from a guy who writes a comic book blog … but reading this series for the first time recently was my first exposure to Todd McFarlane’s pencils. (Remember, I was in a comics cold sleep for decades). Most artists are a product of their age but I have to say that McFarlane’s pencils haven’t aged well. Aside from a select few panels I found his work static and overly posed. The range of expression in his humans was limited — a lot of clenched jaws and 80s hair — but he drew a pretty mean-looking Hulk.
Yeah, he’ll never amount to anything.
Anyway, I found this series a bit of a let-down, and can only assume the esteem in which it is held is largely due to Incredible Hulk having been such a terrible book before the Peter David gave it a fresh take. To be fair, these issues are just the start of David’s decade-long run on the character. I’ll come back and give the series another chance, but this year-long arc was enough for now.
LBG Letter Grade For This Run: C+
* * * * *
Jungle Action #6-18 September 1973-November 1975
I filled in my collection of Jungle Action at San Diego Comic-Con for a song, and I touched on my affection for Black Panther in a previous column, but I must still rank this series as a disappointment. Make no mistake — this is an historic run that scores high points for ambition and degree of difficulty. It has a minority character in a leading role, it eschews standard superheroics for a tale of African civil war, and it can lay claim to being the first graphic novel. Author Don McGregor approaches his subject with intelligence, examining themes of betrayal and the horror of war, and the art and page layouts from artists Rich Buckler and Billy Graham were brash and fresh for the era.
My problem with the book is entirely down to Don McGregor’s writing style, which employs a tortured syntax that just never flowed for me. Read the two-page spread below and decide for yourself — it may work for you, and it may not, but either way you have to admit McGregor’s style demands a different kind of attention from the reader. I will concede that he may be an acquired taste, but it is not a taste I want to acquire — I reprogrammed my brain to read Patrick O’Brian but I’m not going to do the same thing for Black Panther.
So the problem with Jungle Action may be with the reader and not the book, but I found this a run to be admired, rather than enjoyed.
LBG Letter Grade For This Run: C
* * * * *
Daredevil #20-49, September 1966-February 1969
With the grim & gritty Frank Miller Daredevil so firmly engrained in my mind it is a bit jarring to go back to the character’s original “swashbuckling,” smart-Alec personality. And as much as I hate to disparage the original, the wise-cracking Matt Murdoch does come off a bit dim-witted in this run, showing little of his supposedly keen legal and seeming something of an airhead as he stumbles through romantic misunderstandings with Karen Page. A convoluted subplot where Daredevil tries to maintain his secret identity by masquerading as his wild and crazy “twin brother” Mark Murdoch has not aged well at all.
Stan Lee’s plotting is heavily reliant on gimmicks. Daredevil is rendered genuinely blind! Daredevil dresses up like Thor, and meets the real God of Thunder! Daredevil is about to be unmasked on live television! The villains are a third-string bunch, too — Stilt Man, The Beetle, The Trapster, The Owl — yeesh! Even when Doctor Doom shows up it’s for a silly body/mind swap story that doesn’t quite work. It’s pretty tiresome stuff, even by Silver Age standards, but the series is rescued by Gene Colan’s flowing pencils, which seem full of motion (and emotion) even when his subjects are at rest.
So effective is his action that I’ve long overlooked another of Gene Colan’s strengths — he was an excellent draftsman, too, and his automobiles, store fronts, and urban landscapes lend an additional air of authenticity to Daredevil’s street-level adventures.
The later half of the run improves a bit. Daredevil’s battle with Captain America in issue #43 is one of the classic stories of the age, and issue #47′s “Brother, Take My Hand” is melodramatic in a good way, as Matt Murdoch finally uses some of his lawyer smarts to help a blinded veteran. But overall, these issues aren’t Stan Lee’s finest moment as a writer, which is a real shame, because if the script had been as strong as the pencils, this would have been a run for the ages.
LBG Letter Grade For This Run: C+
* * * * *
The New Teen Titans #1-25, November 1980-November 1982
I took the plunge on the New Teen Titans Omnibus when I realized the twenty-five books it covered almost exactly corresponded with the issues missing from my collection. While the stories in this run are classic, the Omnibus is a bit less so, with an oddly stiff binding that sometimes makes it difficult to see the interior edges of the pages, and an introduction from author Marv Wolfman that apparently dates to some earlier collection, rather than offering fresh perspective on the occasion of this particular republication.
But it’s the content that counts, and returning to the Titans after all these years did not disappoint, though DC’s answer to Marvel’s X-Men seems quaint by modern standards, a Silver Age book in Bronze Age clothing. The stories are straight-ahead, uncomplicated, and compressed in old-school fashion, with heroes leaping directly into the action, and narrating their use of powers, their identities, and their inner conflicts so readers have no doubt who they are and what they are doing.
doing what they’re doing, saying what they’re doing, saying what’s happening, and showing it all at once
George Perez’s art is clear, clean, manically detailed, and displayed in deep focus, each page laid out with the precision of Dutch tulip fields — a perfect order of squares and rectangles parsing out consistently-paced superhero action. With its occasional “Epilogs” and portrait-emblazoned splash screen “Roll Calls” the book hearkens to Justice Leagues past, and the narrative captions used to set up some scenes might comfortably be narrated by Ted Knight, the voice-of-god storyteller from a 1970s Superfriends cartoons.
Marv Wolfman’s scripts reveal teenage yearnings in most un-teenaged fashion, his characters almost perfectly self-aware in the way they emote, stating out loud their insecurities and needs where the genuine article would more likely be sullen, or confused, or capricious in coming to grips with issues that can’t identify, let alone articulate.
self-help Robin saves himself a bundle on analyst bills
But for a series where all the gears are on the outside, it works, and works wonderfully, giving our teen cast a richly detailed and evolving characterization. Like the book itself, our characters are orderly, proscribed, and predictable, even when they are coming off the rails. In a way the stories remind me of later-day Star Trek teleplays, with their A and B-stories, their arcs, their spotlit characters, and the sense of a not-so-invisible storytelling hand that will wrap this thing up, one way or the other, by the end of the current episode.
remind me to renew my subscription to the “Underworld Star!”
It’s a world where the bad guys call themselves “The Fearsome Five” and put an ad in the newspaper to fill out their roster. The tales are unambiguously about good versus evil. There are no shadows here and no shades of grey, in the story or the art. The heroes may argue with each other over methods or objectives, but there’s never a doubt about who the baddies are. And lest demons like Trigon think we find them cute for sporting Bullwinkle antlers, he drives home his point by killing little girls and blowing up planets (for starters).
don’t let those Bullwinkle antlers fool you …
It’s remarkable how the book handles heavy issues with a light touch. Raven is the daughter of a woman wedded to a demon by her coven; Donna Troy is sexually beguiled by a Greek Titan; Starfire was sold into slavery — but the story doesn’t dwell on salacious details, instead concentrating on the strengths of each character in overcoming these tragedies. The tales imply rape and genocide but remain nonetheless sunlit and optimistic even in their darkest moments, and it’s not that these events lack weight so much as the glossy nature of the storytelling is magnetically repelled from the grimmest corners of this particular comic book universe. The New Teen Titans are nostalgic, refreshing, and a pretty much perfect example of its form.
LBG Letter Grade For This Run: B+
* * * * *
Avengers #1-35 September 1963-December 1966
Full of anticipation for this year’s Avengers movie, and armed with a Marvel Digital Unlimited subscription, this seemed an ideal time to revisit the original run of the Avengers. The origin tale — with Iron Man, Thor, and the Hulk thrown together with all the chemistry of strangers stuck in an elevator — was familiar, but the rest of the run was new to me, as I first came to the Avengers in 1974. Jack Kirby’s pencils on the first six issues were serviceable, but the Don Heck run that followed was genuinely dire — twenty-nine issues of artistic bad road.
Heck, Don, this just stinks!
The first dozen issues are a bumpy ride, though they have an endearing, “gee whiz” Silver Age charm, with the Avengers democratically rotating their leadership responsibilities, and Rick Jones hanging around and coordinating the operations of his “teen brigade” via ham radio. With Tony Stark determined to hide behind his Iron Man identity, the way is clear for Ant Man/Giant Man to be the brains of the outfit, and that character is the best-realized cast member for the first year of the book, as his powers are (amazingly) used to clever effect, and Hank Pym comes off as a level-headed man of science. The Wasp is a one-note bubble-brain, though, and the internal conflict of the book is limited to arguing with (and about) the Hulk.
The book finds its stride with issue #16, when the headlining heroes are jettisoned, and only Captain America sticks around, to lead a spare parts team of Hawkeye, Quicksilver, and the Scarlet Witch as replacement Avengers. Now the book starts to simmer with internal conflict, as everyone seems to want Cap’s job leading the team, and the series begins to benefit from its own history, with villains like Kang returning to challenge the Avengers anew. So, too, do classic Avengers themes begin to emerge, with villains turning good (the Swordsman, the Black Widow, and an earlier version of the Black Knight figure prominently in this run, while the Avengers Hawkeye, Scarlet Witch, and Quicksilver all overcome villainous origins to join the team); the Avengers enjoying an uneasy relationship with government authorities eager to regulate them or shut them down; Captain America proving more entertaining here than in his own book; Hank Pym’s revolving identities; and continuing obsessions over bylaws, memberships, and leadership. We’re also introduced to characters that would figure prominently in later Avengers lore (like Wonder Man) and we get more Baron Zemo than anyone should have to endure.
The book would truly come into its own with the Roy Thomas/John Buscema run that kicked off in issue #41, but this early run is still a lot of fun (despite Don Heck), and it is a joy to watch the Avengers tropes appear. Plus you can watch Tony Stark smoke as he recharges his ticker!
The series does bottom out a time or two but the overall trend is up and to the right — even after all these years, it is still worth watching the Avengers assemble!
LBG Letter Grade For This Run: B
NEXT WEDNESDAY: #32 Panel Gallery: To Me, My Board!
Posted on January 18, 2012, in Reviews and tagged Avengers, Black Panther, Daredevil, Don Heck, Don McGregor, Gene Colan, George Perez, Hulk, Incredible Hulk, Jungle Action, Marv Wolfman, New Teen Titans, Peter David, Stan Lee, Todd McFarlane. Bookmark the permalink. 43 Comments.
Cool format, getting chunks of the LBG together like this.
TITANS TOGETHER! For a Bronze Age superhero book, that’s an A despite the “I get it already, Marv” scripting. B+ for the medium – fair enough. Anything less than a B and we would have had to use the Ultimate Nullifier on you.
Panther surfing a pterodactyl = awesome. We read that run just last year for the first time, skipping over the captions when it got too heavy-handed. Sometimes, you know, a guy can just walk into a cave and go, “Hey tramp, you kill those dudes?” But McGregor wants to wring every drop out of that moment like it’s the last page on earth. We treated it as optional poetry contributing to the epic scale of the pterodactyl surfing and tyrannosaur trouncing.
I may yet bump New Teen Titans up to an A-minus, I’ve likely underrated that series (just as I’ve persistently overrated Conan). It’s my class so I get to be the report card tyrant but I have enough books graded now that I can start to look at how things fall on the curve. I haven’t given a lot of “A” grades but I also haven’t gotten back to my favorite books yet, either (you can pencil in Swamp Thing and Master of Kung Fu in the “A” range, for example, the Batman run I intend to review may get there too).
Glad the format worked for you … the Titans and Black Panther reviews were long-gestating. It took me awhile to accept that the stubs I’d written for those books weren’t going to flower into full reviews. Getting my Marvel Digital Sub made it all come together, as I banged quickly through those Daredevil, Hulk, and Avengers books, and had a few ideas to share but nothing so in depth as what I have coming up for Defenders in a couple weeks. So mini-reviews seemed a good way to go. I may do “Beneath The Longbox Shortbox” in a couple weeks if the stars line up right. I’ve been reading the original run of Doctor Strange in Strange Tales, which would be a good fit. Just need four more books!
I’m debuting a new kind of column next week, too, with my first “Panel Gallery,” spotlighting visual cliches from Marvel books — let me know what you think.
And now that you mention it, I can totally see how that Panther run would hit you square in your dinosaur fetish. Skimming McGregor’s denser captions is an excellent tactic, wish I’d tumbled to that when I was struggling through the series last summer!
Those early Daredevils are a hoot. They took all the elements that worked in Spider-Man, only they make all the characters grown-ups and put them in a law office, because, y’know, kids love the intricacies of the law.
I think the Titans stuff holds up as well. It has to fall into that “classic” category – and a lot of that stuff that Wolfman did (characters calling each other by name all the time, stating their powers, talking about what they’re going to do while they do it), is pretty much a straight line from Lee/Kirby to Kirby solo to Claremont’s X-Men to Marv.
Marv had some great Marvel work in the ’70s and that long run on Tomb Of Dracula is the highlight for me, then he did the Titans and followed that up with Crisis. It’s a trifecta of great comics and he deserves big kudos for that and more.
[And I’m more than a little biased because while his house was being repaired after the Northridge earthquake, we gave him some cubicle space at Malibu Comics so he could drop in, use the phone, send some faxes, makes copies and conduct a little business. I loved seeing him stroll around the office.]
(It’s Gene Colan that really rescues those Daredevils for me.)
You’re right, of course, that the tendency to overwrite/overstate is hardly unique to Marv, and I probably shouldn’t leave that corpse on his doorstep. I’ve been reading a lot of Stan Lee Silver Age stuff lately and of course that’s just the way it’s done; I think the reason it leaped off the page for me in Titans is that I remembered the book being more modern. The series has modern themes, and George Perez was part of a new look in his day, but the story telling is kind of old fashioned (and I mean that in a nice way, with all the affection a guy who writes a Bronze Age comic blog can muster). It makes New Teen Titans a sort of hybrid, or transitional book, between a nostalgic age and a modern age I hold in considerably lower esteem.
(You guys have just about convinced me to raise that letter grade on Titans.)
I forgot that you worked with Marv for awhile at Malbu (he had a Bravura title with you, didn’t he?). I met Marv briefly when he was editor over as Disney for comics. He gave me a shot at doing a Chip & Dale script and I totally blew it; I always felt bad about that. Nice guy.
Yeah, Marv and artist Shawn McManus had a snappy Bravura title called The Man Called A•X, and it was fortunate that the first series got to finish before the imprint was shuttered. Marv’s a great guy – he wasn’t in the office that long and certainly not every day, but he’d pop in, do his stuff and hang out. It was very surreal to walk out of my office – “Oh, look, Marv’s here and he’s sending a fax.” Spending time with him, and Howard Chaykin, was a highlight of my Malibu years.
I hope that he’ll write some kind of memoir of his time in comics. He broke in when the old guard of DC – Kanigher, Boltinoff, Julie Schwartz and others – was still guarding, and he was part of the new people coming in and stirring things up, pre-Direct Market. I’d love to read more about the behind-the-scenes stuff at both DC and Marvel during that time.
Aside from either originating or being perfected by Stan, the overwriting/overstating technique feels like it’s part of the mantra of “every issue could be someone’s first” so that while the plot may be running through a couple of issues, at least you know who the players are and what they can do. Plus, now that we can read two years worth of comics in one sitting, it’s not how they were originally created, so the flaws – and redundancies – are more obvious now.
Good post as always. Looking forward to next week’s!
Tom’s right on about these things: Reading them in one sitting gives a different experience than waiting 30-60 days. And, Titans was right at the end of the “news rack” age of comics where I remember picking things up fairly randomly as a kid.
Marvel made a nice move in the 2000s to put in title pages that recapped the story, gave the run down on the players and characters, and so on. That eliminated the need for all this over-explanatory dialogue.
And though I hate to say it, we are not the intended audience for these books. This was a book for literate teenagers and young college students primarily. Another way to grade them would be: How well written were they for their intended audience? We wouldn’t give Brothers Karamazov a D+ just because a six year old found the dialogue impenetrable. So it may be unfair to judge Titans by the same standards of say, Concrete, Lucifer, Criminal, or Zap.
It is a good point, both of you, about the original context of these stories. I know that “Every story could be a reader’s first” was a mantra for Jim Shooter in his Marvel EIC years. In the news stand era there was the additional complication of spotty distribution that might mean even dedicated readers would miss an issue or two. Reading the letter columns of those Captain America Tales of Suspense reprints last year revealed many fans of the day were opposed to stories that ran more than one issue, and that had to have something to do with the disappointment of picking up an issue and finding it continued the tale of an issue they’d missed, or put them on the hook for finding the rest of the story during the brief window it would be racked at the corner drug store. The single-issue story (and the artful recap of What Has Gone Before) are both staples of the form that have all-but-vanished in this era of “writing for the trade.”
And Mars, I do try to filter myself when writing these reviews — a big part of this blog is trying to understand the differences between myself at twelve and myself at fifty, so I consciously try to recapture my original emotions about a book, and evaluate how those feelings have changed. I know full well most of these stories aren’t going to hold up (and even when a book completely crashes and burns, as was the case with Deathlok and to a lesser extent Micronauts, I try to drill back down to what it was about those books that excited the affection of my younger self). The grade and assessment I offered Titans (for all that I may have sold it short) really is on a continuum with the other books I’ve reviewed on the blog, and not an attempt to compare it to other forms of fiction or film. And by that standard it rated very high indeed (of contemporary books I’ve only graded Simonson’s Thor higher). Titans actually was one of those select books that was better than I remembered — but it was also different than I remembered, and part of what was different was the style of the storytelling.
Right on, Paul. We dig the self-discovery undercurrent that separates your site from other Bronze Age blogs. …and, things like the ‘self-help Robin’ caption that is still cracking us up. Maybe you are even moving in the direction of identifying not only what makes a comic stand the test of time, but also what makes a story appeal to all ages – an area where we are especially clueless.
Shooter was right. Until about the age of 14, the only place we could get comics was the Magic Mart and the Walgreens within walking distance of our parents’ house. Collecting stuff like the 6-issue Man of Steel series, or the 6-issue Dreadstar and Company reprints – we must have walked to the store a million times waiting for the day the issue would hit the stands, and still missed them. ^%#@*($*&!!!
I don’t think I have a clue about all-ages appeal, actually. That big, shiny, colorful, New Teen Titans Omnibus sat unread on my twelve-year-old son Jack’s nightstand for weeks over the holiday. I really thought he’d tumble to this particular collection but no dice. He’ll sometimes read a World of Warcraft graphic novel, but for the most part he’s got his nose glued in his iPod (and hasn’t had any enthusiasm for reading comics on that platform, either). I can’t rag on him too bad for the iPod thing because that is also my business and livelihood, but it seems increasingly certain the Comics Geek Gene has skipped a generation in my family.
Kids these days!
And your Walgreens story reminds me that in the summer of 1974 my comic stand was at the end of a long, long hill in Hollywood, and that I used to walk down there seemingly every day to spend my quarters on Marvel Comics. (Uphill both ways, of course). Fortunately I didn’t miss a lot of issues even in those newsstand distribution days because just down Hollywood Boulevard (near the Chinese Theater) was Collector’s Book Store (also called Bennet’s Book Store I think) which was a direct market comic book shop before there was a direct market, or even comic book shops for that matter. And they had EVERYTHING, including the last three or four month’s worth of any Marvel book, so if I got hooked on Iron Man, I could go back and get the previous several issues, and if I missed an issue of Thor, well, I could fill in that run as well. If I could go back in time with a couple hundred dollars in my pocket what treasures I might pull out of that cave. Long gone now, sadly.
Pingback: #30 Limited Universe « Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: #35 Beneath The Longbox Shortbox « Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: #41 Flashback 1956! « Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: #50 Fantastic Fiftieth Issue! « Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: #51 Escape From The Longbox Shortbox « Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Top Ten Captain America Villains | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: New Teen Titans Gallery | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Avengers Assemble Gallery | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Avengers Assemble Gallery | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Avengers Gallery | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Black Panther Gallery | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Hulk Gallery | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Daredevil Gallery | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Write This Page! | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Daredevil Debuts On Netflix! | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Avengers Age of Ultron! | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Ant-Man | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: New Avengers #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Uncanny Avengers #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Deadpool #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: All-New Hawkeye #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Vision #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: All-New All-Different Avengers #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Black Knight #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Daredevil #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Scarlet Witch #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Totally Awesome Hulk #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Spider-Man/Deadpool #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Daredevil 2 Arrives On Netflix! | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Black Widow #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Mockingbird #1 | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: Digesting The Avengers | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: “A” Is For … | Longbox Graveyard
Pingback: “J” Is For … | Longbox Graveyard